Well I don't want to discuss the topic of whether the reversal of the .xxx decision was right or wrong, this is another thread, I think. I do, however, want to challenge your assumption that the voices from GAC, at the Luxembourg meeting, had no effect whatsoever. If you say they didn't this would mean that the only body making or influencing decision at ICANN is the US DoC, with or without a JPA? I don't believe this is true, or at least I don't want to believe that it is true.